Follow us
Publications Commentary Research People Events News Resources and Videos About IFS
Home Publications Herding in Quality Assessment: An Application to Organ Transplantation

Herding in Quality Assessment: An Application to Organ Transplantation

Stephanie de Mel, Kaivan Munshi, Soenje Reiche and Hamid Sabourian
IFS Working Paper W20/22

There are many economic environments in which an object is offered sequentially to prospective buyers. It is often observed that once the object for sale is turned down by one or more agents, those that follow do the same. One explanation that has been proposed for this phenomenon, which goes back to Banerjee (1992) and Bikhchandani (1992) is that agents making choices further down the line rationally ignore their own assessment of the object's quality and herd behind their predecessors. We develop novel tests to detect information-based herding, based on heterogeneity in agent ability, together with a methodology to quantify its welfare consequences, that are applied to organ transplantation in the U.K. We find that herding is common and is an important contributor to the high rate at which organs are rejected by transplant centers (and subsequently discarded). However, herding does not raise discard rates much above the level that would be obtained if private assessments were made publicly available. Instead, the (limited) information contained in predecessors' decisions substantially reduces the acceptance of bad organs. This is because in our application (i) high ability centers are often willing to deviate from the herd and follow their own positive signals, and (ii) sequences are exogenously terminated relatively quickly.

More on this topic

Journal article | Journal of the European Economic Association
This paper uses a dataset from Tanzania with information on consumption, income and income shocks within and across family networks.
IFS Working Paper W20/21
Youth unemployment in Ghana increases in parental wealth. This occurs because, without unemployment insurance, only workers with sufficiently high parental wealth can afford to remain unemployed, and do so to search for scarce, high-productivity jobs.
This report presents the main findings of the project “Improving early childhood development in rural Ghana through scalable low-cost community-run play schemes''.
IFS Working Paper W20/14
Can consumption taxes reduce inequality in developing countries?
Briefing note
This brief addresses the fiscal response to the coronavirus pandemic, arguing that governments could make use of the opportunities this shock provides to make changes to tax systems now that might be politically difficult later.