Follow us
Publications Commentary Research People Events News Resources and Videos About IFS
Home Publications Estimating Endogenous Effects on Ordinal Outcomes

Estimating Endogenous Effects on Ordinal Outcomes

Cemmap Working Paper CWP66/19

Recent research underscores the sensitivity of conclusions drawn from the application of econometric methods devised for quantitative outcome variables to data featuring ordinal outcomes. The issue is particularly acute in the analysis of happiness data, for which no natural cardinal scale exists, and which is thus routinely collected by ordinal response. With ordinal responses, comparisons of means across different populations and the signs of OLS regression coefficients have been shown to be sensitive to monotonic transformations of the cardinal scale onto which ordinal responses are mapped.


In many applications featuring ordered outcomes, including responses to happiness surveys, researchers may wish to study the impact of a ceteris paribus change in certain variables induced by a policy shift. Insofar as some of these variables may be manipulated by the individuals involved, they may be endogenous. This paper examines the use of instrumental variable (IV) methods to measure the effect of such changes. While linear IV estimators suffer from the same pitfalls as averages and OLS coefficient estimates when outcome variables are ordinal, nonlinear models that explicitly respect the ordered nature of the response variable can be used. This is demonstrated with an application to the study of the effect of neighborhood characteristics on subjective well-being among participants in the Moving to Opportunity housing voucher experiment. In this context, the application of nonlinear IV models can be used to estimate marginal effects and counterfactual probabilities of categorical responses induced by changes in neighborhood characteristics such as the level of neighborhood poverty.

More on this topic

Cemmap Working Paper CWP4/20
This article provides a selective review on the recent literature on econometric models of network formation.
Cemmap Working Paper CWP3/20
This paper introduces measures for how each moment contributes to the precision of parameter estimates in GMM settings.
Cemmap Working Paper CWP1/20
We study the incidental parameter problem in "three-way" Poisson Pseudo-Maximum Likelihood "PPML" gravity models recently recommended for identifying the effects of trade policies.
Cemmap Working Paper CWP2/20
We propose an optimal-transport-based matching method to nonparametrically estimate linear models with independent latent variables.
Journal article | Macroeconomic Dynamics
Consumption Euler equations are important tools in empirical macroeconomics. When estimated on micro data, they are typically linearized, so standard IV or GMM methods can be employed to deal with the measurement error that is endemic to survey data. However, linearization, in turn, may induce ...